“Or you’re different people from different realities,” Sylar pipes up from the corner where he’s currently beating everyone at a game of Best Brooder. He’s struggling right now and the best way he knows how to deal with that is by being a dick. It’s true. Jack would collaborate.

“Or,” Steve steps in, “it’s because we’ve lost a good chunk of our memories— Pete, anything weird when you showed up? Something out of place? Missing time?”